Skip to main content

The Trustworthiness of Charities

Navigating the Captain Tom Controversy and Local Heroes

The Captain Tom Foundation, inspired by the heroic fundraising efforts of the late Sir Captain Tom Moore during the COVID-19 pandemic, quickly became a symbol of hope and unity. It raised a staggering £39 million to support the National Health Service and other charities, reflecting the compassion and generosity of people from all walks of life. However, the subsequent revelations of mismanagement and inefficient fund allocation cast a shadow over the charity's legacy. It is a painful reminder that even well-intentioned organisations, when not held accountable, can falter and betray the trust of their supporters.

This incident is not an isolated one. Across the globe, large-scale charities have faced criticism and skepticism regarding their use of funds. The transparency of their operations often leaves much to be desired, and the gap between donors' expectations and the actual impact of their donations widens. Such incidents not only damage the reputation of the organisations themselves but can also discourage potential supporters from contributing to other good causes.

Nevertheless, it is crucial not to paint all charities with the same broad brush. Many smaller, grassroots organisations work tirelessly at the community level, addressing pressing issues with a commitment to transparency and integrity. These unsung heroes exemplify the very essence of charitable work and often go unnoticed by the general public and media. Their work is not only more focused but also reflects the true spirit of giving, with minimal overhead costs and a direct impact on those in need.

These smaller community causes often operate on limited budgets and depend on the unwavering dedication of their volunteers. Unlike their larger counterparts, they have a stronger connection to the communities they serve. As a result, they are more agile, responsive, and efficient in their efforts to create change. They are a testament to the fact that charitable work is not solely about big numbers but, more importantly, about the lives they touch and the problems they solve.

My own charity, TheGivingMachine has historically been focused on these smaller charities, schools and community organisations that have limited fundraising resources and so I always feel bad when a few people and organisations tarnish the work of so many thousands of others.

In light of recent controversies, it is evident that when popular campaigns and donations sums are involved, the charitable sector needs better oversight, transparency, and accountability. Donors have the right to know how their contributions are being used and what impact they are making. Large charities and campaigns should always ensure that their internal controls and communication strategies are fit for purpose to maintain the trust of their supporters and indeed of the 3rd sector in general.

However, this should not discourage us from supporting smaller community causes that are making a real difference on the ground. Their stories of dedication and integrity serve as a reminder that genuine, meaningful change can be achieved, even without substantial financial resources.

As responsible supporters and donors, we must approach our giving with discernment and scrutiny, ensuring that our contributions align with organisations that share our values and commitment to making the world a better place. It is also up to us to be vigilant and demand transparency, regardless of the size of the charity we choose to support.

The recent controversy surrounding the Captain Tom Foundation is a stark reminder of the importance of holding charities accountable for their actions. However, it is also an opportunity to shine a light on the many smaller community causes that work tirelessly, often in the shadows, to make a positive impact in the lives of those who need it the most. By supporting these local heroes and demanding transparency from larger organisations, we can collectively ensure that the spirit of giving and charity remains a force for good in our world.


About the author

Richard Morris

Richard is a co-founder and Chief Executive of the charity.  He’s a successful entrepreneur in business and technology both in the UK and USA and wanted to leverage technology for good with his co-founders.  He manages TheGivingMachine strategy, development programme, leads major projects and business development.  He also consults for businesses wanting to adopt a more people, planet, profit culture.

Join us on social media

We value your privacy

We use technology such as cookies on our site to personalise content, provide social media features, and analyse our traffic. 

Learn more about how we use cookies to enhance your browsing experience.